There was once a man, let’s call him Steve. Steve was a good man, and had a good job, where he helped people.
But Steve also used to pretend to be a doctor in his spare time. He created an entirely different identity for himself, as James Jones MD. Steve discovered that people liked him as a doctor, and he liked being a doctor as well. So he used to talk to other doctors, and learned more about medicine, and being a doctor.
Eventually he started seeing patients. Just a few at first, but soon more and more people. And he was really good at it. So he kept pretending to be a doctor.
Steve really liked helping people, and he thought he could keep doing it as a doctor, although he still felt guilty sometimes.
Often he wanted to close the clinic, and stop treating patients. But some of them were sick, and couldn’t afford other doctors. He convinced himself that they needed his treatment, more than they needed the truth. They needed James Jones.
Except that some really sick people came to him, and he agreed to operate on them. So he treated them, and tried to operate. He knew all about operating, because he had spoken to other doctors about it, and had read all the books.
But he made some mistakes. He sewed them up, but he caused complications.
And Mark noticed. Mark was a paramedic, and was a friend of both James Jones MD, and some of the patients who got hurt. And Mark was worried.
So he spoke to James.
And Steve told him everything.
Mark was afraid that if the truth came out about James Jones MD, then people would be even more hurt. So he agreed to say nothing. On condition that Steve close the clinic, and never operate on anyone again. Steve was as good as his word, and closed the clinic. He even apologised to some of the patients who he had hurt.
Mark promised he would never tell anyone what had happened. He even made contact with Steve where he lived, in his real job, and agreed to still be his friend.
Steven had been trying to get away from the world of medicine for a long time, but didn’t know how. He was afraid of being found out. He really thought people would hate him, but instead they forgave him. Many of the people he spoke to were shocked, but they agreed to still be his friend. They wanted to be friends with Steve, not James Jones MD.
Not everyone was though, and some of the patients were never able to recover from their wounds. With some care from real doctors, they were able to patch over some of the injuries. But the scars took longer to heal.
It’s quite a long story, and rather pointless. So why do I tell you?
-
Steve tried to justify his untruth with good intentions, but that was wrong. So he kept lying, and people got hurt.
-
Mark also agreed to lie, with good intentions. Does that make his actions as bad as Steve’s?
-
Steve found forgiveness, and release from something that he had been trying to get away from for years. He found grace and mercy he never expected, and it lightened his load.
-
But his release was at the expense of real hurt to other people. People who were innocent victims in this. People who had to get over being violated by a “doctor” under false pretences. Would they have been better off not knowing?
-
As a Christian, is it wrong that Mark was as concerned with Steve’s wellbeing as with his “victims”?
“Then you will know the truth, and the truth will set you free.”
John 8:32
Where is the morality in this situation? Is it ever right to lie for someone? Are there times when you shouldn’t tell the truth, because people might get hurt?
This story is based on real events I have witnessed recently. Any similarity between characters in the story and people in your own life is purely co-incidental.